Introduction
Dogs have long held a complex place in Islamic tradition and Muslim culture. While dogs are considered impure in mainstream Islam, some Muslims regard dogs fondly as loyal companions. The Islamic view of dogs stems from interpretations of teachings in the Quran and hadith, but cultural attitudes also play a role. There is diversity of opinion within Muslim communities about the cleanliness and permissibility of dogs. This article will explore the origins of Islamic views on dogs, cultural differences, evolving perspectives, and advice for dog owners in Muslim households.
Islamic Teachings on Dogs
The Quran does not explicitly prohibit dog ownership. Some Muslims interpret verses like Surah Al-Kahf 18:18 to imply that dogs are permitted for purposes like guarding or hunting (Animals in Islam).
However, there are hadiths that establish rules about interacting with dogs. Many hadiths say that angels will not enter a house with dogs or pictures (Dogs in ancient Islamic culture). Other hadiths say that if a dog drinks from the same vessel as a person, it must be washed seven times. There are also prohibitions on selling or keeping dogs, unless they serve a function like herding, hunting, or protection.
These hadiths have led many Muslims to view dogs, especially their saliva, as ritually impure. But the hadiths do not completely forbid dogs either. They lay out guidelines for when and how dogs can be kept in accordance with Islamic principles.
Cultural Differences
Views on dogs vary greatly between different Muslim cultures and regions. Many traditional Islamic cultures regard dogs as unclean animals, based on certain Islamic teachings, and thus do not commonly keep them as pets. However, this view is not universal. In the Western world, Muslims are increasingly embracing dogs as pets. For example, surveys show that over 20% of Muslim households in the U.S. own dogs. This cultural difference highlights that views on dogs are influenced by regional traditions and personal choice, beyond just Islamic scriptures.
In regions like the Middle East and North Africa, there are cultural taboos against keeping dogs inside the home. Dogs are more commonly used for guarding and working purposes. However, in Western countries like the U.S. and Europe, many Muslims keep dogs as pets and cherished companions. The cultural assimilation of Muslims in the West contributes to greater acceptance of dogs as part of the family. Yet traditional Islamic reservations about dogs still persist among some segments of Western Muslim communities.
Overall, the prevalence of dogs as pets among Muslims correlates much more closely with regional culture rather than just religious beliefs alone. While classical Islamic texts express concerns about dogs, cultural context plays a major role in how these teachings are interpreted and practiced day-to-day.
Positive Views
While some Muslims view dogs as unclean, others highlight more positive aspects and permissible uses for dogs in Islam. Many Muslims recognize dogs can serve useful purposes like providing security, herding livestock, or assisting in hunting (Source 1). According to scholar Khaled Abou El Fadl, the majority of scholars consider dogs’ saliva to be ritually impure, but allow Muslims to keep dogs for working purposes such as guarding the home or farm, or to use dogs when out hunting (Source 2).
There are also religious allowances made for guide dogs assisting the visually impaired. While touching dogs is still controversial, many modern Muslim scholars grant exceptions for blind Muslims to use guide dogs out of necessity.
Concerns About Saliva
Many Islamic teachings discuss the ritual impurity (najasah) of dog saliva and the need to wash yourself after contact with dogs before prayer. According to one hadith, the Prophet Muhammad said: “If a dog drinks from the vessel of anyone of you, let him wash it seven times, and rub it with Earth the eighth time.”[1]
Based on such hadiths, many Muslim scholars consider dog saliva to be ritually impure and believe that any utensil or object licked by a dog must be washed seven times to purify it. If the saliva touches human skin or clothes, those areas must also be washed seven times.[2] These rules lead some Muslims to avoid keeping dogs as pets or allowing them indoors.
Additionally, Muslims are advised not to pray or perform other acts of worship right after having contact with a dog’s saliva until they have performed ritual purification. This concerns some Muslims and contributes to negative views about allowing dogs near prayer spaces.
[1] https://islamqa.info/en/answers/976/najaasah-impurity-of-dogs-and-the-ruling-on-keeping-a-dog
[2] https://www.learnreligions.com/dogs-in-islam-2004392
Varying Opinions
There is a range of opinions among Muslims on the permissibility of dogs, from considering them completely halal (allowed) to completely haram (forbidden).
Some conservative scholars consider dogs to be ritually impure (najis) and haram to keep as pets based on certain hadiths that warn against dogs [1]. However, other moderate scholars argue that these rules were situational and not meant as a complete prohibition [2].
There are also differences between scholarly opinions and cultural practices of regular Muslims. While scholars debate, many Muslim families do keep dogs as pets, though take precautions about cleanliness. Ultimately, views on dogs vary significantly based on cultural context, interpretations of Islamic law, and personal choice.
Changes Over Time
Historically, dogs were viewed more negatively in Islamic culture. According to some hadiths (sayings of the Prophet Muhammad), dogs were considered impure and keeping them as pets was discouraged.[1] However, these views have evolved over time. Today, many Muslims keep dogs as pets and working animals.
There are a few reasons for this shift. As Muslims came into increased contact with Western cultures where dogs are common pets, attitudes began changing. Additionally, a deeper scholarly examination of Islamic texts revealed differences of opinion on the permissibility of dogs. This led to greater openness to accepting dogs. Finally, the practical benefits of dogs as helpers, security, and loyal companions convinced many Muslims that keeping them is worthwhile.
While some conservative scholars still discourage dog ownership, there is now greater diversity of thought on this issue. Many Muslims believe that properly caring for dogs is in line with Islamic principles of compassion and stewardship of creation. This growing acceptance has allowed dogs to become much more commonplace as pets in Muslim communities worldwide.
Advice For Dog Owners
For Muslims who choose to own dogs, there are some considerations to keep in mind out of respect for Islamic traditions:
When guests come over, keep the dog out of the room or in a separate area. Some Muslims may be uncomfortable eating or praying in the same room as dogs due to cleanliness rules. Accommodate guests by keeping the dog confined or outside when they visit.
Train the dog not to lick people or household surfaces. The saliva of dogs is seen as ritually impure in Islam. While views differ on touching dogs, many wish to avoid contact with dog saliva. Train the dog not to jump up or lick.
Bathe and groom the dog regularly to keep clean and minimize odors. Out of respect for praying areas, avoid letting dogs into rooms used for prayer. Thoroughly clean any areas where a dog has been.
When walking in public, keep the dog leashed and away from other people if possible. Be aware some may actively avoid close contact with dogs for religious reasons.
Research hotels or housing that accommodate pets, when traveling with dogs. Do not assume Muslim friends or relatives can host dogs in their homes.
Overall, balance dog ownership with respect for the different views on dogs within the Muslim community. Make accommodations when needed, while providing proper care and training for pets.
Conclusion
The topic of dogs in Islam is a nuanced issue with a variety of views. While some Muslims regard dogs as unclean, others have more positive opinions. Increased acceptance of dogs has been seen in recent times. With open and respectful discussion, Muslims and dogs can peacefully coexist.
There is not one single viewpoint on dogs in Islam. Opinions range from cautiously avoiding dogs to happily owning them as pets. Geographic, cultural, and individual differences shape perspectives. Rigid judgements are unwise.
As societies modernize, attitudes often soften. More Muslims are welcoming dogs into their lives. This reflects evolving interpretations of scripture, increased exposure to dogs, and pragmatic considerations. Though some reservations remain, dogs are being seen in a more positive light.
For respectful coexistence, it is important to understand different views on dogs in Islam. Open-minded dialogue and tolerance pave the path forward. With compassion on all sides, Muslim communities and dog owners can find common ground.
References
These are the sources the writer used to obtain information for this article:
-[Author], [Title of book], [Publisher], [Year of publication]
-[Author], [Title of article], [Title of journal or website], [Date of publication]
-Interviews conducted by the author with [names and credentials], [date of interviews]
-[Name of organization or company], [Title of report], [Date published]
-[Database name], [Name of organization providing database], [Date accessed]
-[Title of webpage], [Website name], [Date accessed]