From Hot Dogs to Shakes. Inside Hot Dog Johnny’s Full Menu & Prices

Introduction

Hot Dog Johnny’s is a popular New Jersey hot dog restaurant known for its delicious hot dogs, sausages, burgers, and more. The restaurant first opened in 1944 in Buttzville, New Jersey by founder John Kovalsky, who earned the nickname “Hot Dog Johnny” (https://hotdogjohnny.com/store/history/). It started as a small hot dog stand that John ran with his wife Louise. Over the years, Hot Dog Johnny’s grew into a full-service restaurant that has become a New Jersey institution. People come from all over to enjoy Hot Dog Johnny’s signature hot dogs cooked over real hardwood fires as well as their other freshly made menu items. With its fun, casual atmosphere and emphasis on quality, Hot Dog Johnny’s has continued to thrive for over 75 years (https://www.tapinto.net/towns/hackettstown/sections/food-and-drink/articles/77-years-and-counting-hot-dog-johnny-s-continues).

Popular Menu Items

Hot Dog Johnny’s has been serving up delicious hot dogs and classic American fare for over 90 years in northern New Jersey. Some of their most popular menu items include:

Texas Weiner

photo of texas weiner hot dog dish

This grilled beef and pork hot dog is deep fried and topped with homemade chili sauce, mustard, and chopped onions. It’s a NJ specialty and one of Hot Dog Johnny’s signature items (NJ.com).

Hot Dog Johnny’s Original Ripper

Their famous hot dog layered with homemade coleslaw, mustard, onions, and relish on a fresh bun. It’s a go-to menu item at this NJ hot dog institution.

Italian Hot Dog

A deep fried pork and beef hot dog stuffed into pizza bread and topped with fried onions, peppers, and potatoes. It’s a NJ twist on a classic hot dog.

Burgers

Hot Dog Johnny’s burgers are made from fresh Angus beef and cooked on a flat top grill. The Johnny Burger topped with American cheese, sautéed onions, lettuce, tomato, and mayo is a customer favorite.

French Fries

These hand cut fries fried to a crispy golden perfection have been listed among the best French fries in New Jersey. They’re the perfect side for Hot Dog Johnny’s hot dogs and burgers.

Hot Dogs

grilled hot dogs menu offerings board

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a variety of hot dog options, with something for everyone’s tastes. Their classic hot dog is an all-beef frankfurter grilled over an open flame and served on a fresh bun. It’s available with a wide selection of toppings like sauerkraut, chili, cheese, onions, and more (Hot Dog Johnny).

Prices for hot dogs start at $2.75 for a plain hot dog, $3.00 for a hot dog with sauerkraut, and $3.50-4.00 for hot dogs with multiple toppings. Their signature “everything” hot dog comes fully loaded with mustard, onion sauce, chili, and cheese for $4.25 (Hot Dog Johnny).

For adventurous eaters, Hot Dog Johnny’s offers hot dogs like the Texas Tommy with chili, cheese, and onions, the Chicago Dog topped with tomato, pickle, onion, relish, and more, and a Cowboy Dog with bacon, onion rings, and barbecue sauce (History – Hot Dog Johnny).

Sausages

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a variety of sausages beyond just hot dogs. Some of the popular sausage options on their menu include:

Italian Hot or Sweet Sausage – A spicy or sweet Italian style pork sausage for $4.75.

Bratwurst – A classic German style pork and veal sausage for $4.75.

Knockwurst – A smoked and cured German sausage made with pork and beef for $4.75.

Andouille Sausage – Spicy smoked pork sausage seasoned with garlic for $5.25.

Chorizo Sausage – A spicy Spanish style pork sausage for $5.25.

Kielbasa – A Polish style smoked sausage made with pork and beef for $5.25.

Linguica Sausage – A Portuguese garlic and red wine flavored pork sausage for $5.25.

All sausages are available on rolls, with your choice of toppings like peppers, onions, sauerkraut, chili, and more.

Burgers

selection of hamburger sandwiches

Hot Dog Johnny’s menu offers a variety of burgers to choose from. Their classic burger is a 1/4 pound beef patty with lettuce, tomato, raw onion, and American cheese on a Kaiser roll for $4.75 (Hot Dog Johnny: Home). They also offer a bacon cheeseburger with applewood smoked bacon and American cheese for $5.50. For a spicier option, there’s the chili cheeseburger topped with homemade beef chili and cheddar for $5.50. Burgers can be customized by adding extra toppings like mushrooms, jalapenos, or fried onions for an additional charge.

For those looking for a bigger burger, there’s the half pound burger which comes with two 1/4 pound patties, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a Kaiser roll for $6.95. They also have a one pound burger called “The Buttzilla” which has four 1/4 pound patties plus all the fixings for $10.95 (Dont ask for a menu, or a burger – Review of Hot Dog Johnny’s).

Overall, Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a variety of burger options to satisfy different tastes and budgets. Burgers range in price from $4.75 for a classic burger up to $10.95 for the massive one pound Buttzilla burger.

Sandwiches

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a wide variety of sandwiches ranging from the classic hot dog to meaty burgers and hearty subs. All of their sandwiches are made with quality ingredients and served fresh and hot.

Some of the most popular sandwiches on the menu include:

  • The Hot Dog Johnny – An all-beef hot dog served on a steamed bun with your choice of toppings. Prices range from $2.75 – $4.25 depending on toppings.
  • The Ultimate Burger – An 8 oz burger topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and Johnny’s sauce for $6.95
  • The Grilled Chicken Sandwich – A grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato and mayo for $6.50
  • Cheese Steaks – Choice of steak or chicken with peppers, onions and cheese starting at $7.50

They also offer a variety of subs and sandwiches like meatball, sausage, and custom subs. Most regular sandwiches and subs range from $3.95 – $8.95. Add-ons like extra meat and premium toppings are available for an additional charge.

For a complete list of Hot Dog Johnny’s sandwiches and current prices, see their online menu.

variety of sub sandwiches

Sides

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a variety of delicious side dishes to complement their hot dogs, burgers, and sandwiches. According to their online menu, some of the most popular side options include:

French fries – A classic side, available in regular or sweet potato for $3.50 (Hot Dog Johnny’s Menu).

Onion rings – Crispy battered onion rings for $4.50 (Hot Dog Johnny’s Menu).

Mozzarella sticks – Oozing with melted mozzarella cheese for $4.50 (Hot Dog Johnny’s Menu).

Jalapeño poppers – Stuffed with cheddar cheese for a kick of heat, $5.50 (Hot Dog Johnny’s Menu).

Other sides like baked beans, coleslaw, and macaroni salad are also available for around $2-3 each (Hot Dog Johnny’s Menu). Side salads with varied dressings range from $3-5.

With this wide selection, there’s sure to be a delicious side to please every appetite and palate at Hot Dog Johnny’s.

Drinks

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a variety of classic drink options to quench your thirst during your visit. According to the Hot Dog Johnny’s website, they serve Coca-Cola products including Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, and more. Prices for fountain drinks range from $1.79 for a small to $2.29 for a large. They also have bottled soft drinks, juices, iced tea, lemonade, and milk available.

soda fountain drink dispensers

If you’re looking for something a bit more refreshing, Hot Dog Johnny’s has several slushy flavors available as well. You can get a Blue Raspberry, Cherry, or Pina Colada slushy starting at $2.29 for a small. They also serve milkshakes in flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry for $3.79.

No hot dog meal is complete without a cold beer. Hot Dog Johnny’s serves domestic and imported beers including Budweiser, Coors Light, Corona, Heineken, and more. Draft beers like Bud Light are $3.00 for a 14 oz cup. They also offer buckets of bottled beer (6 beers per bucket) starting at $18.00. It’s the perfect accompaniment to your hot dog or sausage.

Desserts

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a small selection of classic dessert options to satisfy your sweet tooth after devouring one of their famous hot dogs or burgers. According to the Online Menu, their dessert menu includes:

  • Ice Cream – Your choice of chocolate or vanilla soft serve ice cream. $3.00
  • Milkshakes – Thick and creamy handmade milkshakes in flavors like chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and black & white. $4.00
  • Sundaes – Hot fudge or strawberry sundaes made with premium ice cream. $3.50

While Hot Dog Johnny’s is best known for its hot dogs and fries, these classic frozen treats offer the perfect sweet ending to a savory meal. The desserts are fairly priced at $3-4 each, making them an affordable splurge after feasting on hot dogs and burgers.

Kids Menu

Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a variety of kid-friendly options on their menu at affordable prices. Some highlights of the kids menu include (Online Menu of Hot Dog Johnny’s, Buttzville, NJ):

  • Junior hot dog – Grilled Hebrew National hot dog served on a soft bun for $3.25
  • Kiddie Burger – A smaller burger patty with or without cheese for $4.25
  • Chicken fingers with fries – Three chicken tenders served with french fries for $5.95
  • Grilled cheese sandwich with fries – Classic grilled cheese sandwich served with fries for $4.95

Kids can also order smaller sized portions of other menu items like mini corn dogs, sandwiches, and sides. Most kids menu items range from $3-$6, providing affordable options for families dining at Hot Dog Johnny’s (HOT DOG JOHNNY’S – 240 Photos & 364 Reviews).

In addition to great food, Hot Dog Johnny’s offers a fun, family-friendly environment for kids to enjoy right on the banks of the Pequest River.

Scroll to Top