The Science Behind Your Dog’s Pooping Preferences

Introduction

Most dog owners are no stranger to their pup’s peculiar potty habits. When nature calls, dogs have a number of interesting routines and preferences for selecting the perfect place to relieve themselves. From circling to sniffing, it turns out that where a dog chooses to go is more complex than you might think.

While we often consider bathroom habits purely from a human perspective, the way dogs decide where to poop and pee relies heavily on their evolutionary history and innate instincts. The canine sense of smell plays an especially important role. Let’s explore some of the key factors that influence how a dog picks that perfect spot.

Olfactory Exploration

Dogs have an excellent sense of smell, with up to 300 million olfactory receptors in their noses compared to only 6 million in humans (Rover). They use smell to gather information about their environment. When looking for a place to poop, dogs will first sniff around the area thoroughly to find the perfect spot.

They are particularly interested in smelling for urine or feces left by other dogs, as these scents provide a form of communication. Older scents give dogs information about which areas are frequented by other dogs for elimination (Floofins). By sniffing and exploring, they can find an ideal location that meets their criteria.

This exploratory process is why dogs often seem to take a long time and meander around before finally picking a spot to poop. They are carefully using their powerful sense of smell to make an informed decision (Union Lake Veterinary Hospital). So while it may seem like they are wasting time, they are actually gathering important olfactory information to find the perfect place.

Preference for Soil

dog sniffing grass before pooping

Many dogs prefer to eliminate on softer, natural surfaces like soil or grass rather than hard surfaces such as concrete or asphalt. There are several reasons why dogs gravitate towards soil or grass to poop.

Dogs have highly sensitive paw pads that can be irritated by rough textures like concrete or rocks. The soft, cool earth is much more comfortable under their paws when squatting to poop. Additionally, female dogs may associate the compressible soil or grass with an ideal denning site for future puppies.

The earth also offers better traction compared to slippery hard surfaces, allowing the dog to dig and paw at the ground to get comfortable. The act of digging in the soil may be an innate behavior tied to covering up their waste in the wild. Grass similarly allows them to circle, sniff, dig, and paw before selecting the perfect spot.

Soil and grass also provide ideal conditions for dispersing and absorbing urine and feces. Porous, organic surfaces like soil do a better job neutralizing odors compared to impervious concrete or asphalt. For dogs that are scent-marking their territory, the absorbent earth retains those smells better.

While grass or soil is ideal, dogs can be trained to potty on designated artificial turf patches or even puppy pads if needed. But most dogs have an instinctual preference for natural, softer surfaces when nature calls.

Scent Marking

Some dogs will use their poop to mark territory. According to the article Understanding Dog Territorial Marking, some dogs will strategically deposit their feces in certain locations as a way to mark their territory. Unneutered male dogs in particular are prone to marking behaviors – both with urine and poop – as they seek to assert their dominance.

The article Stop Your Dog From Marking explains that unneutered male dogs may assume the role of pack leader and mark territory with their poop. This tendency can be corrected through training, neutering, and removing any previously soiled areas that might trigger repeat marking.

Overall, scent marking with feces, while not as common as urine marking, can occur especially in unneutered male dogs seeking to establish dominance and mark their territory.

Privacy Preference

Dogs tend to prefer private, hidden locations when finding a place to poop. This preference likely stems from their wolf ancestry, as wolves would hide their scent markings to avoid alerting prey or rival packs. According to this article, many dogs seek out bushes, tall grass, or other concealed areas that provide cover when defecating. Some dogs even turn their backs to their owners or caretakers to get more privacy. While this behavior may seem odd to humans, it provides dogs with a greater sense of security and minimizes unwanted attention during a vulnerable process.

Researchers suggest that privacy gives dogs the opportunity to fully relax and complete elimination without interruption. As pack animals, dogs aim to avoid showing weakness in front of perceived competitors. Pooping involves positioning their bodies in a crouched, exposed stance, which leaves them susceptible to potential threats. By seeking seclusion, dogs can relieve themselves comfortably without the stress of onlookers — be they animal or human.

dog pooping behind bushes

Elimination Communication

Dogs have developed ways to communicate their need to poop to their owners and caretakers. This allows dogs to eliminate in appropriate designated areas and prevents soiling inside the home. Dogs rely on both behavioral cues and vocalizations to indicate they need to go outside to poop.

Some of the most common behavioral signals a dog needs to defecate include pacing, circling, sniffing around, and tail stiffening when near the door to go outside 1. A dog may also watch you intently or make direct eye contact when it’s time to go out. Some dogs may whine, bark, or make whimpering noises when they need a bathroom break. Learning to identify these signals allows owners to promptly let their dog outside to do its business.

Establishing a consistent potty schedule is also helpful for good elimination communication. Taking a dog out to poop at regular intervals throughout the day trains the body’s natural rhythms. Dogs should go out first thing in the morning, after meals, after napping, and before bedtime. Keeping to this routine allows the owner to anticipate when the dog will likely need to poop.

With time and positive reinforcement, such as treats and praise, dogs can learn to ask to go out by ringing a bell or using a verbal cue like “outside.” This clear signaling prevents accidents and keeps the home clean.

Influence of Diet

A dog’s diet can have a significant impact on their poop location habits. Dogs fed a diet high in fiber tend to need to poop more frequently and have larger stools (https://www.petplate.com/blog/dog-poop-health/). This can make it more challenging for them to “hold it” until they find an appropriate location. In contrast, dogs fed high protein, low fiber, or raw diets will typically have smaller, firmer stools that are easier to retain (https://doggielawn.com/blogs/blog/differences-between-puppy-adult-and-senior-dog-foods-and-how-they-affect-poop). Studies have found dogs fed human-grade dog foods have much less fecal output compared to kibble, likely due to differences in digestibility and fiber content (https://www.aaha.org/publications/newstat/articles/2021-02/study-human-grade-dog-food-diets-may-lead-to-less-pooping/).

Overall, the type and amount of food impacts stool volume and urgency to defecate. Dogs on diets that lead to large, loose stools will likely need to poop more urgently and frequently, making it harder for them to be selective about an elimination location.

Environmental Factors

dog refusing to poop in snow

The weather and other environmental conditions can significantly influence a dog’s choice of where to eliminate. Dogs prefer to poop in a location protected from the elements. Rain, snow, wind, extreme heat or cold can all deter a dog from pooping in an exposed area.

Loud noises, like traffic or construction, may also lead a dog to seek out a more peaceful, private spot. Busy areas with a lot of foot traffic are usually avoided as well. Dogs prefer an elimination area free of pests like insects that might disturb them mid-poop.

In winter, many dogs dislike pooping on snow or frozen ground and will try to hold it until they can find a clear grassy patch, wood chips, or other thawed surface (1). Dogs may need encouragement and positive reinforcement to poop despite snowy conditions. Providing a sheltered potty area can help (2).

During storms, some dogs become anxious or afraid to go outside at all. Patience and routines can help a dog overcome reluctance to potty in the rain. Allow extra time and stand with them under an umbrella or sheltered area (3). Consider a raincoat for very adverse conditions.

Health Considerations

A dog’s poop can reveal important information about their health. Certain illnesses and conditions can affect a dog’s ability to find an appropriate place to poop.

Diseases of the stomach and intestines, like inflammatory bowel disease, can cause changes in stool frequency, consistency, and urgency, making it difficult for dogs to wait until they find a suitable location (Source). Rectal and colon cancers may also lead to straining and constipation, forcing dogs to poop wherever they can (Source).

Parasitic infections, like giardia or coccidia, can cause loose stools or diarrhea that dogs may not be able to control long enough to find an ideal spot (Source). Bacterial infections and viral illnesses often lead to urgent, frequent diarrhea as well (Source).

Overall, any condition impacting digestion and bowel movements can affect a dog’s ability to be selective and find the right place to poop.

Conclusion

happy healthy dog pooping outdoors

In summary, dogs have a variety of interesting behaviors when determining where to poop. From relying on their keen sense of smell to scout for the perfect location, to expressing preferences for softer soil or secluded areas to avoid interruption, dogs engage in complex rituals around elimination. While challenging for pet owners, these behaviors stem from natural canine instincts around territory, communication, and health. With patience and by catering to their needs, we can better accommodate our four-legged friends’ potty requirements.

An interesting fact is that some researchers believe dogs align themselves with the Earth’s magnetic field when pooping. This preference for “north-south orientation” may help dogs stay attuned to their surroundings and aware of any approaching threats while in such a vulnerable position.

Scroll to Top