What is Kibble?
Kibble is a type of dry dog food that consists of meat meals, grain, fat, and other ingredients that are blended together and processed into bite-sized pieces. The kibble pieces are created through an extrusion process where the ingredients are cooked under high heat and pressure, then pushed through a die that forms the characteristic kibble shapes.
Some key features of kibble are:
- Low moisture content, usually around 10% or less
- Shelf-stable, does not require refrigeration
- Crunchy, intended to help clean dog’s teeth
- Processed into uniform sizes and shapes
The extrusion process cooks the starch components in the food, gelatinizing them to allow digestion. Meat meals and fat provide protein and an appealing taste for dogs. After extrusion, the kibble is dried to reduce moisture and promote shelf stability.
Overall, the manufacturing process and ingredients used allow kibble to be a convenient and affordable option for feeding dogs. The dry format makes it easy to store and serve. While inexpensive, most kibble provides complete and balanced nutrition when formulated properly.
Types of Kibble
There are several different types of kibble dog food available, formulated for dogs with different nutritional needs and preferences.
Some common types of kibble include:
- Puppy kibble – Formulated for growing puppies, with extra calories, protein, and nutrients.
- Adult kibble – For healthy adult dogs with balanced nutrition.
- Senior kibble – Made for older dogs with modified protein, fat, and ingredients that are easier to digest.
- Breed-specific kibble – Tailored to the nutritional needs of certain dog breeds.
- Grain-free kibble – Uses protein sources like meat, fish, and legumes instead of grains.
- Prescription kibble – For dogs with specific health conditions, under veterinary advice.
Kibble can come in different shapes and sizes – small bite-sized pieces, larger chunks, oblong, round, or square shapes. The texture also varies between smooth, crunchy pieces or ones with a rougher surface.
Ingredients in kibble range from whole meat, fish or poultry, to legumes, grains, vegetables, oils, and other nutrient sources. The formulation and combination of ingredients depends on the purpose of the specific kibble recipe.
Nutritional Value
Kibble is designed to provide complete and balanced nutrition for dogs according to AAFCO standards (https://www.petmd.com/dog/nutrition/evr_dg_whats_in_a_balanced_dog_food). The main nutrients in kibble are protein, fat, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals.
On average, kibble contains about 26% protein, 15% fat, and 50% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8373756/). However, there is variation between brands and formulas. For example, high protein kibbles may contain over 30% protein while lower protein kibbles may have 20% or less.
Some controversial kibble ingredients include corn, wheat, soy, and by-products. Critics argue these ingredients are simply fillers with little nutritional value. However, defenders claim they can be nutritious parts of a balanced diet if processed properly.
Compared to wet and raw diets, kibble tends to be lower in moisture, protein, and fat but higher in carbohydrates. This is because the kibble cooking process removes moisture. Some claim wet or raw foods are healthier, while others argue kibble’s dryness and carbs make it a complete diet.
Cost Comparison
When it comes to cost, kibble is generally the most affordable option for feeding dogs compared to wet food, raw food, and home-cooked meals. According to Canine Health, the average cost of premium kibble is around $1.30 per day or $39 per month for a 50 lb dog. This equates to approximately $0.50 per pound. In comparison, the average cost of wet food is $2-$3 per day, raw food $3-$5 per day, and home-cooked meals $10+ per day for a dog of the same size.
Several factors affect the cost of kibble including brand, recipe, package size, and where it’s purchased. Mass-market and grocery store brands like Pedigree and Purina Dog Chow offer kibble for as low as $0.50 per pound. Premium brands like Blue Buffalo and Wellness can cost $1-4 per pound. Freeze dried, fresh, or prescription kibble is even pricier at $5+ per pound. Buying larger bags (20+ lbs) brings down the per pound cost. Purchasing at big box stores is cheaper than pet supply stores or online.
Benefits of Kibble
Kibble offers several benefits that make it a convenient choice for many dog owners. Some of the key advantages of dry kibble include:
Convenience and ease of use. Kibble can be easily scooped out of a bag and poured into a bowl. It does not require any preparation or refrigeration.
Doesn’t require refrigeration. An unopened bag of kibble has a long shelf life and does not need to be refrigerated like wet canned food.
Helps clean teeth. The crunchy texture of kibble helps scrape plaque and tartar off a dog’s teeth as they chew. This provides a degree of dental benefit.
Often easier to digest. Many dogs find kibble easier on their stomachs than wet food. The dry texture contains less fat and moisture.
Overall, kibble offers a convenient way to feed dogs that aligns with many owners’ lifestyles. It does not require much preparation and avoids the need for refrigeration. The crunchy texture also provides some dental benefits. For these reasons, kibble remains a popular choice for feeding dogs.
Downsides of Kibble
While dry kibble certainly has its advantages in terms of convenience and cost, there are some potential downsides to consider as well:
Kibble can contribute to dehydration in dogs if they do not drink enough water. The dry food absorbs moisture during digestion, so dogs fed only kibble may require more water intake compared to wet or fresh foods (Bayshore Vets).
There is also a risk of contamination and recalls with dry kibble. Kibble often contains grains, fillers and preservatives that can allow bacteria or mold to grow, especially if stored improperly. Several brands of kibble have been recalled due to contamination concerns over the years (Feeding My Dog Breed).
Kibble tends to contain less meat content compared to wet food, fresh food or raw diets. The high amount of grain and carbohydrates can be problematic for some dogs (Raw Bistro).
Some dogs eat kibble too quickly due to the small, dry pieces. This can potentially lead to choking, bloating or gastrointestinal issues in susceptible dogs.
Kibble Brand Comparison
When it comes to kibble, there are many brands to choose from. Some of the top names in kibble include Purina, Hill’s Science Diet, Royal Canin, Iams, and Eukanuba. Here’s an overview and comparison of these major kibble brands:
Ingredients: These major brands use corn, wheat, soy and by-products as primary ingredients. More premium kibble brands like Orijen and Acana use fresh meats, fish and vegetables as their main ingredients. In general, the more meat and whole ingredients near the top of the ingredients list, the better quality the kibble.
Pricing: Purina, Iams and Eukanuba are typically the most budget-friendly options. Hill’s Science Diet and Royal Canin cost more for their veterinarian-formulated recipes. Orijen and Acana are premium-priced kibbles.
Recalls: Most major kibble brands have faced recalls over the years. This is often due to contamination at the manufacturing facilities. Make sure to research the recall history of any brand you consider.
Specialty Recipes: Many brands offer recipes tailored to different dog life stages and health conditions. For example, Hill’s Science Diet has recipes specifically for puppies, seniors and dogs with sensitivities. Be sure to choose a kibble suited to your dog’s unique needs.
While the major kibble brands offer affordability and wide availability, smaller premium brands like Orijen and Acana boast better ingredients and fewer recalls. Consider your budget, your dog’s health needs and brand reputation when choosing a kibble.
Storing and Feeding
Proper storage of kibble is important to maintain freshness and prevent bugs or other pests from getting into the food. The FDA recommends refrigerating or throwing out any unused wet food, and storing dry kibble in a cool, dry place in an airtight container. Dry kibble can typically be stored for around 6 weeks after opening when stored properly.
It’s best to store kibble in its original bag inside an airtight plastic or metal container, which provides an extra barrier against moisture, bugs, and other contaminants (1). Metal containers often have sealable lids that keep air out. Some pet owners also use food-grade plastic bins or BPA-free containers with airtight lids (2). Only scoop out the amount of kibble needed at each meal, then reseal the container.
Feeding schedules vary based on your dog’s age, size, and activity level. Typically adult dogs do well with two meals per day, while puppies may need three or more feedings. Always follow the feeding recommendations on your kibble’s packaging. The amount can be adjusted gradually based on your dog’s body condition.
Slow feeders and food puzzle toys are great for dogs who eat too quickly. These tools encourage slower eating by making your dog work for their food through moving kibble around or solving a puzzle to access it. This prevents gulping down food too fast, which can lead to vomiting or bloat.
Making Your Own Kibble
Many dog owners are interested in making their own homemade dog food, including kibble. While homemade dog food has some benefits, it also takes more time and effort than buying commercial kibble.
To make your own kibble at home, you will need a food dehydrator or very low oven, and probably a meat grinder to process ingredients. Common recipes include a protein source like chicken, beef, turkey or fish combined with vegetables, brown rice, eggs, and supplements like fish oil.
Some benefits of homemade kibble include:
- Control over all ingredients
- Can customize to your dog’s needs
- Avoid preservatives or additives
- Appealing to picky eaters
However, there are also downsides such as:
- Time consuming to make
- Difficult to formulate balanced nutrition
- Risk of food spoilage or contamination
- More expensive than commercial kibble
Overall, making your own kibble at home can be a rewarding project for some dog owners willing to invest the time and effort. But it may be unrealistic for most busy owners compared to quality commercial kibble options.
The Verdict on Kibble
Overall, kibble can be a nutritious and convenient choice for feeding dogs when you select a high-quality brand. Kibble provides a complete, balanced diet in an easy to store and serve dry format. The crunchy texture also helps clean dogs’ teeth. However, some critics argue kibble is highly processed and lacks the moisture content of fresh foods. Here are some tips on when kibble makes sense as a dog food choice:
Is Kibble Good for Dogs? A Guide to Choosing Dry Dog …
The power of high-quality Kibble – Scratch Pet Food
– For healthy dogs without special dietary needs, kibble can provide complete nutrition in an easy format. It’s inexpensive per serving compared to fresh foods.
– For dogs with allergies or intolerances, high-quality kibble with limited ingredients is an option. Look for novel proteins and grain-free recipes.
– Active, high-energy dogs can benefit from kibble’s calorie density to support their needs. Just watch portion sizes.
– Puppies should be fed kibble specifically formulated for their growth and developmental needs.
– When traveling or outdoor adventuring with dogs, kibble offers convenience without refrigeration.
When selecting a kibble, prioritize quality over cost. Look for brands that use high-quality ingredients, avoid fillers, and undergo feeding trials. Veterinary recommendation, word of mouth, and online reviews can help identify excellent kibbles to try.