Should Your Dog’s Bedroom Be in Your Bedroom? The Pros and Cons of Having a Dog Crate in Your Room

Introduction

Crate training is an essential part of raising a happy, healthy, and well-behaved dog. The location where you place the crate in your home can impact the effectiveness of crate training. The two most common locations people place dog crates are the bedroom or the living room. Both locations have their pros and cons in terms of crate training success. In this article, we will analyze the benefits and drawbacks of having your dog’s crate in the bedroom versus the living room. With the right information, you can make an informed decision about the ideal crate location that will set your dog up for crate training success.

Pros of Crate in Bedroom

Having the crate in the bedroom provides several benefits for both you and your puppy. One major pro is that being nearby helps your puppy feel more secure at night. Puppies often experience anxiety when sleeping alone in an unfamiliar environment. According to K9 Basics, having the crate in your bedroom makes crate training easier by reassuring your puppy and helping them adjust.

pros of bedroom crate location

Another advantage is that it’s much easier to let your puppy out to potty during the night if their crate is right there in your bedroom. This prevents accidents and reinforces good potty habits. No one wants to be stumbling through the house at 3am to let a pup out!

Finally, having your new puppy sleep near you allows more bonding time. As AKC notes, the crate helps strengthen the human-canine bond. You’ll both get used to each other’s presence and sounds at night.

Cons of Crate in Bedroom

cons of bedroom crate location

Having the dog crate in the bedroom can have some drawbacks that are worth considering. One potential issue is that the dog could disturb human sleep. Dogs may whine, bark, or make other noises during the night which can disrupt sleep patterns, especially for light sleepers. This could lead to exhaustion and irritability for the humans in the household (Source).

The crate also takes up valuable floor space in the bedroom. Bedrooms in many homes are already small, and a large crate can make the room feel cramped and cluttered. Humans may trip over the crate at night when getting in and out of bed in a dark room.

It can also be challenging to keep the bedroom clean and free of dog hair and dander with the dog sleeping there. Dog hair tends to get embedded in carpets, bedding, and furniture which requires constant vacuuming and laundering to control. People with allergies may react to the dander and have difficulty sleeping as well.

Pros of Crate in Living Room

pros of living room crate location

Placing your dog’s crate in the living room can have some advantages compared to the bedroom. Here are some of the main pros of having the crate in the living room:

Less disruptive to human sleep – Having the crate in the bedroom means your dog’s noises at night will likely wake you up. Your rest is less likely to be disturbed with the crate located outside the bedroom (Source).

More space for crate setup – The living room tends to offer more open floor space than a bedroom. This allows you to purchase a larger crate and set it up with more room around it for accessories (Source).

Contain messes and household impact to one room – Accidents and chewing are more likely for young or untrained dogs. Keeping the crate in the living room localizes any damage to that area of the home.

Cons of Crate in Living Room

cons of living room crate location

One of the key downsides of keeping the dog crate in the living room is that the dog can feel more isolated from the family, especially at night when everyone is sleeping in the bedrooms upstairs. Dogs are pack animals and prefer to be near their family members both during the day and at night. Having the crate downstairs in the living room separates them from their human pack, which can cause anxiety.

Additionally, keeping the crate in the living room can make frequent potty breaks more difficult, especially for young puppies. They may need to be let out every few hours in the night, which becomes problematic if the crate is not near where you sleep. This can lead to whining or barking when the puppy needs to go out.

Related to being isolated, some dogs may bark or whine more if their crate is in the living room instead of the bedroom. Especially at night, they want comfort and closeness to their owners. The living room crate location can exacerbate separation anxiety and nervousness in some dogs [1].

Ideal Crate Setup

Choosing the proper size crate for your dog is crucial. The crate should be just large enough for them to stand up, turn around, and lie down comfortably – no more. If the crate is too large, your dog may go potty in one corner and sleep in the other (Preventive Vet, 2019). Provide a comfy bed or pad and avoid crates with exposed bars on the floor.

Allow access to water unless you are actively crate training for short durations. Do not leave puppies in a crate for more than 2-3 hours. Provide safe chewing toys to help relieve boredom and anxiety. Acclimate your dog slowly, starting with short sessions of just 10-15 minutes in the crate with praise/treats. Gradually increase duration as they adjust.

If your dog struggles with being crated, consider alternatives like a puppy playpen or gating off a safe area instead. The crate should be a place of comfort, not stress. Work on positive associations by feeding meals inside and providing high-value treats. Remain patient and allow your dog to adjust at their own pace.

When to Move Crate Locations

There are certain times when it may make sense to move your dog’s crate location to better suit their needs or changes in your home situation:

As your puppy ages and becomes house trained, you may want to shift their crate to a different room like the living room or kitchen to give them more freedom. Puppies initially kept in the bedroom at night for easy potty training access can transition to sleeping in a central area as they mature (source).

When introducing a new pet like another dog, it can be wise to move the existing dog’s crate to manage tensions and territory disputes. Keeping them separated initially with crates in different rooms allows both animals to adjust (source).

Major changes in your family situation like having a new baby may warrant relocating the crate to reduce disruption and manage the dog’s stress. Moving the crate from bedroom to living room lets them be near you without waking the baby.

Training for Crate Location

Proper training is essential for helping your dog adjust to their crate location. Focus on positive reinforcement techniques to create a calming environment.

When first moving the crate, expect an adjustment period. Be patient and consistent. Praise and reward your dog for calm behavior in the crate using treats or favorite toys. You want them to associate the crate with positive experiences.

To prevent whining or barking, make sure your dog’s needs are met first – such as taking them on a walk. Provide safe chew toys in the crate and ignore minor protests at first to reinforce the desired behavior. You may need to sleep near the crate initially so they don’t feel isolated.

If barking continues, do not reward the behavior by immediately opening the crate. Wait for a lull first. Stay consistent with training and reinforce quiet time in the crate to overcome separation anxiety. Be patient – crate training can take days or weeks depending on your dog.

With proper acclimation to the new location, your dog can learn to settle in their crate happily.

Lifestyle Factors to Consider

When deciding where to place your dog’s crate, you’ll need to take your lifestyle and your dog’s individual needs into account.

If you have a high energy dog or an active household, having the crate in a high traffic area like the living room may make sense. This allows your dog to be part of the action and not feel isolated. However, a dog that needs more peace and quiet would likely do better with their crate in the bedroom https://shophiddin.com/blogs/news/where-to-put-a-dog-crate-in-the-house.

The layout of your home is also a factor. If you have limited space, you may not have flexibility on crate placement. Owners of large, multi-story homes need to think about which floors the dog will spend the most time on. Easy access to the crate on that level is ideal.

Consider your dog’s temperament as well. Anxious dogs often benefit from having their crate placed in a quiet, low traffic area like a bedroom so they don’t get overstimulated https://be.chewy.com/the-best-place-for-a-dogs-crate/. Highly social dogs would do better with a more central living room location.

Conclusion

In summary, there are pros and cons to having the dog crate in both the bedroom and living room. Key factors to consider are the dog’s anxiety levels, house layout, your lifestyle and habits, and good crate training. While the bedroom offers more privacy and containment, the living room provides your dog with your company and activity. There is no universally “correct” place, but rather what works best for each individual dog and household.

Based on the balanced information presented, the ideal recommendation is to start the crate in your bedroom for puppies or anxious dogs. This allows for better confinement when you’re away or sleeping. Then as your dog becomes comfortable and trained, you can consider moving the crate to a high-traffic area for more environmental acclimation. Just be sure to transition locations gradually.

Most importantly, proper crate training from an early age will enable your dog to happily accept their crate wherever you choose to place it. With patience and positive reinforcement, they will see their crate as a comfortable den rather than a punitive measure. Training therefore outweighs location in ensuring your dog has a positive crate experience.

Scroll to Top