Inside or Out? The Great Debate on Where Your Dog Should Live

Introduction

The question of whether a dog should live indoors or outdoors is one many pet owners wrestle with. Both indoor and outdoor living have their pros and cons. While some believe outdoor dogs get more exercise and are better guard dogs, experts say living indoors is generally better for a dog’s physical and mental health. This article will outline some of the key factors to consider when deciding if your dog should live inside or outside, including safety, health, socialization, training, bonding, space needs, and outdoor conditions.

Safety

safety considerations for indoor dogs
Keeping a dog inside the home can help protect it from many environmental dangers outside (https://www.security.org/resources/keeping-pets-safe/). Dangers outside the home include extreme weather, wildlife, insects, ingesting toxins, getting lost, and traffic accidents. Inside, owners can regulate the temperature to keep a dog comfortable and prevent heat stroke or hypothermia. The controlled indoor setting reduces the risk of dog fights with strays, bites from wildlife, bee stings, getting tangled in brush, or eating something poisonous. Screened windows and doors keep bugs out. An indoor dog is less likely to escape the confined space compared to a large, open backyard. Owners can also better supervise an indoor dog and prevent household accidents like electric cord chewing. Proper indoor dog-proofing such as storing chemicals out of reach and covering electric cords can greatly minimize risks (https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/articles/welfare-dogs-need-suitable-environment). With attentive owners, an indoor setting offers safety.

Health

Keeping dogs indoors supports their physical health and hygiene in several ways. According to the VCA Animal Hospitals, indoor dogs are less likely to pick up infectious diseases because they have less exposure to other animals that could be carrying viruses or parasites (source). Indoors, their environment can be kept clean and free of waste, which further reduces disease risk. Additionally, indoor dogs tend to get more regular exercise through play and walks with their owners. Regular exercise helps them maintain a healthy weight and avoid obesity-related conditions like arthritis and diabetes.

health benefits of indoor dogs

Owners can more easily monitor an indoor dog’s health and notice any issues early before they become severe. For example, changes in appetite, energy level, or bathroom habits may indicate an underlying health problem. Overall, the controlled indoor environment and close supervision by owners allows for proactive health maintenance through vaccines, parasite prevention, dental care, and veterinary checkups.

Socialization

Proper socialization is extremely important for a dog’s development and quality of life. Dogs are social animals that thrive when they receive regular human interaction and affection. According to the AKC, studies show that owning a dog can increase physical activity and encourage a daily schedule in owners. Dogs that live inside the home tend to be better socialized with humans because they interact more frequently with family members. This leads to a stronger human-dog bond.

Living inside provides more opportunities for a dog to socialize with people. An indoor dog sees family members all day as they go about their daily activities. Frequent positive interactions enable the dog to become comfortable around people. Well-socialized dogs are better behaved in public settings and less fearful of strangers. They can visit places like cafes, stores, and parks without experiencing significant stress. According to Longwood Veterinary Center, socialization leads to dogs getting more exercise, having more fun, and enjoying life more.

Conversely, dogs left isolated outside do not get enough human interaction. This can lead to anxiety, fear aggression, and other problematic behaviors. dogs require daily human interaction and play for proper social development. Living inside the home facilitates this socialization process in a way that outdoor living simply cannot match.

Training

Potty training is one of the most important aspects of training for any dog. In general, smaller dogs that live indoors tend to be easier to housebreak than larger outdoor dogs. There are a few reasons for this:

Indoor dogs have constant access to their owner, allowing for more supervision during the house-training process. This makes it easier to notice pre-potty signals and promptly take the dog outside (1). Additionally, indoor dogs form a closer bond with their owner, making them more responsive to commands and eager to please.

The confined space of a house or apartment means there are less potential potty spots. This helps an indoor dog learn more quickly where it should and shouldn’t go. Outdoor dogs have more freedom and space, making training consistency more difficult (2).

Certain indoor dog breeds like Maltese, Miniature Schnauzer, and Bichon Frise are known to be highly intelligent and eager to please. Their temperament makes house-training simpler compared to independent outdoor breeds (3). With positive reinforcement and consistency, indoor dogs can quickly learn to only relieve themselves in designated outdoor areas.

Bonding

Living indoors alongside their human caretakers allows dogs to foster an exceptionally strong bond and attachment. According to several studies, dogs who share closer proximity with their owners tend to have higher levels of the “love hormone” oxytocin, which promotes bonding and affection. Dogs also understand hundreds of human gestures and cues that facilitate communication and understanding between the species (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10417759/). Spending time together inside the home provides dogs with consistent positive interactions, attention, play, training, and other enriching activities that create a powerful bond.

Some research suggests that female dogs tend to show preference for male caretakers, while male dogs bond more closely with women caretakers (https://www.quora.com/Do-dogs-bond-more-closely-with-women-or-men). However, individual personalities play a significant role. When dogs live harmoniously as family members within the home, they become highly attuned and responsive to the behaviors, emotions, and routines of their human caretakers. This closeness and rapport simply cannot develop to the same degree when dogs live detached from family life outdoors. For those seeking a meaningful, lifelong canine companion, welcoming a dog to share indoor home life is ideal for establishing a profoundly rewarding human-canine bond.

Space Needs

strong bonding with indoor dogs

Dogs that live indoors need enough space to move around comfortably and get adequate exercise. According to the BC SPCA (https://spca.bc.ca/news/exercise-your-dog-indoors/), running up and down stairs gives dogs a great cardio workout. Hiding treats around the house also provides mental stimulation and physical activity as dogs search to find them (https://petcube.com/blog/indoor-dog-exercise/). Apartment dwellers should provide puzzle toys and chews to keep their dogs engaged. Allowing access to multiple rooms prevents boredom. Smaller dogs may be content in a studio apartment, but larger breeds need more square footage to avoid restlessness or destructive behaviors. Providing indoor dogs with daily walks, play time, and environmental enrichment ensures their exercise needs are met within the home.

Outdoor Conditions

Leaving dogs outside in extreme weather can be very dangerous for their health and wellbeing. Both hot and cold temperatures can pose risks to dogs. According to the AKC, temperatures above 90°F can cause heatstroke in dogs, leading to symptoms like heavy panting, glazed eyes, rapid heartbeat, difficulty breathing, excessive thirst, lethargy, fever, vomiting, diarrhea, and even seizures (source). Puppies and small breeds are especially susceptible. In cold weather, dogs left outside without adequate shelter are at risk of hypothermia, frostbitten ears and tail, and death (source). A 2021 study found rural outdoor dogs had increased risk of heat exposure compared to urban dogs.

outdoor condition risks for dogs

To protect dogs’ wellbeing in inclement weather, provide ample shade, ventilation, bedding, and fresh water in hot conditions. In cold weather, ensure a properly insulated and draft-free shelter large enough for the dog to sit and lie down comfortably. Limit time outdoors during temperature extremes. Know the signs of heatstroke and hypothermia so you can act quickly. Consider letting your dog live mostly or fully indoors if you live in an extreme climate.

Guard Dogs

When an outdoor dog is properly trained, it can act as a guard dog to help protect the property. Some of the advantages of dogs for property protection include:

Deterrent – The presence of a dog, especially a large breed, can deter potential intruders from approaching the property. Burglars are less likely to target a home with an outdoor dog.

Alert barking – Outdoor dogs are more alert to noises and movement on the property compared to indoor dogs. Their barking can alert owners of suspicious activity.

Fear factor – The mere presence of a dog on guard can instill fear and make intruders think twice.

However, there are also some potential drawbacks of using dogs as outdoor guardians:

Barking – Dogs left unattended outside frequently can become nuisance barkers, which neighbors may find annoying.

Aggression – Dogs without proper socialization and training may show unwarranted aggression towards visitors or passersby.

Escapes – Dogs may dig under or jump over fences and escape the yard while owners are away.

According to the American Kennel Club, some breeds that excel as guard dogs include German Shepherds, Doberman Pinschers, and Rottweilers (source). However owners must properly train and socialize any dog intended for guard duties.

Conclusion

After reviewing the pros and cons, most experts recommend keeping dogs indoors if possible. Dogs that live inside tend to be healthier, live longer, and have stronger bonds with their families. Living indoors allows dogs to be fully integrated into family life, providing companionship and forming secure relationships through consistent daily interaction. Though there are benefits to having outdoor dogs, such as guarding property or having more space to run, these do not outweigh the advantages of bringing a dog indoors. Dogs are social animals that thrive when treated as part of the household.

Scroll to Top