Introduction
Dog owners often debate which gender makes a better pet. Some swear that male dogs are more affectionate and attentive, while others argue that female dogs are sweeter and more sensitive. At the heart of the debate lies an intriguing question – are boy dogs truly needier than girl dogs?
In this article, we will dive into the research around male and female dog behaviors and personalities. We’ll examine how gender differences emerge, from the earliest weeks of puppyhood into adulthood. Along the way, we’ll consider how factors like breed, training, and the owner’s lifestyle impact a dog’s need for attention and attachment. By the end, you’ll have a deeper understanding of gender differences in dogs, and be equipped to choose the perfect pet for your family.
Background on Dog Behavior
Dogs have evolved from wolves over thousands of years to become dependent on humans for survival and companionship. According to the article on LiveScience, dogs were likely the first animals to be domesticated, originating from wolves as far back as 30,000 years ago. As wolves adapted to live alongside humans and relied on them for food and shelter, they evolved physiologically and behaviorally to become the dogs we know today.
Like humans, dogs are highly social animals with complex emotional needs. Research from the University of Wyoming explains how dogs require affection, attention, exercise and stimulation from their human caretakers (Smith, 2021). Dogs form strong bonds with their owners and can experience emotions like jealousy, grief, anxiety and joy. They are not fully independent animals like wolves, but have deeply integrated into human social groups and family units.
Due to their close relationship with humans over thousands of years, dogs have evolved an innate need for human companionship and interaction. More so than their wolf ancestors, dogs require daily affection, play time, training and attention from their owners to be happy and well-adjusted.
Defining ‘Needy’ Dog Behavior
Needy behavior in dogs often manifests itself through attention-seeking and clinginess. Common signs of a needy dog include:
- Excessive vocalization like whining, barking or howling when left alone
- Destructive behavior like chewing or digging when separated from owners
- Following owners from room to room and demanding constant affection
- Difficulty settling down and relaxing by themselves
- Displaying signs of separation anxiety like pacing, drooling and trembling when an owner leaves
- Becoming overexcited when owners return after an absence
According to PetMD, lapdogs like Shih Tzus tend to be more needy by nature1. Working dogs trained to be dependent can also become clingy. But any breed can develop needy behavior if owners reinforce clinginess.
Neediness often stems from a dog’s insecurity about being alone. They crave constant interaction and affection from their owners. Without proper training and Independence building, needy behavior can become excessive and problematic.
Comparing Male and Female Puppy Behavior
Research has shown some key differences in male and female puppy behavior, even at a young age. According to a comprehensive review from Scandurra et al. (2018), “Behavioral and Perceptual Differences between Sexes in Dogs”, female puppies tend to exhibit more independent behavior compared to males. Females are often satisfied playing alone, while male puppies frequently seek more attention and physical contact.
Male puppies are often considered more “needy” and attached to their owners than females. They desire more petting, handling, and praise. Females can become aloof or indifferent if they don’t receive enough early socialization and attention, but in general are more self-sufficient than males from a young age.
Spaying or neutering puppies impacts hormones and can affect behavior as well. Neutered males often become less assertive but more affectionate and attached. Spayed females tend to be less independent and more attention-seeking than intact females. The differences in social needs between male and female puppies become most apparent after spay/neuter.
Adult Dog Behavior Differences
While there are some general trends in behavior differences between male and female adult dogs, there is significant variation between individuals. Gender is just one factor that impacts a dog’s personality and actions.
Some research suggests that male dogs tend to be more social and attention-seeking compared to females. For example, one study found that male dogs were more likely to approach and make physical contact with a stranger [1]. However, this can vary greatly between individual dogs, with some females being very social and some males more reserved.
Female dogs are sometimes considered more territorial than males, especially intact females. Spayed females may display more aggressive behaviors compared to intact females according to some studies [2]. But again, these are general trends and there are many exceptions.
While gender may play a role, factors like breed, training, socialization, health, and environment often have a bigger impact on an adult dog’s personality and behavior than gender alone.
Impact of Breed
Certain breeds tend to be more “needy” and clingy than others. In particular, herding breeds and companion breeds often exhibit more velcro-like attachment behaviors.
Herding breeds like German Shepherds, Border Collies, and Shetland Sheepdogs were originally bred to work closely with their owners to herd livestock. This close bond and need for direction often translates into clingy tendencies as family dogs.
Companion breeds such as Cavalier King Charles Spaniels and Havanese were bred specifically for human companionship. They thrive on close contact and affection from their owners. Separation anxiety is common in these breeds if left alone for long periods.
Other notoriously clingy breeds are Doberman Pinschers and Vizslas. Dobermans were historically guard dogs who stuck close to their charges. Vizslas are high energy hunting dogs who crave attention and interaction. Both rate among the top “velcro dogs.”
So while clinginess varies from dog to dog, certain breeds are genetically more predisposed to develop stronger bonds and needier behavior with their human families.
Impact of Training
Proper training and socialization from an early age can help reduce needy behaviors in both male and female dogs. Puppies that are exposed to a variety of people, places, and other dogs are less likely to develop separation anxiety and excessive attention-seeking as adult dogs. Obedience training is especially recommended for male dogs, as it teaches them to listen to commands and not act on impulses. According to the ASPCA, male dogs are more likely to jump up, bark, or whine for attention. Working with a professional trainer on basic manners provides an appropriate outlet for their energy. Additionally, training builds confidence in the dog and helps them learn to be more independent. Well-socialized and trained dogs often feel secure enough to entertain themselves and not need constant owner interaction or affection.
Sources:
Impact of Owner
An owner’s personality and lifestyle can influence their dog’s behavior and neediness levels. According to How to deal with a needy dog: The 4 steps you need to know, anxious owners may inadvertently reinforce needy behaviors in their dogs by giving them attention when they whine or bark. Additionally, owners who are home more often and interact frequently with their dogs can enable clingy behaviors.
Owners of needy dogs should aim to provide sufficient physical and mental exercise daily. Taking a dog on regular walks, playing games like fetch, and providing chew toys can help satisfy their needs and curb attention-seeking behaviors. It’s also important that owners set boundaries and ignore attention-seeking behaviors. Providing a dog with their own safe space, like a crate or bed, can teach them to be comfortable alone. Owners may also benefit from obedience training to reinforce good behaviors.
With time and consistency, owners can help an overly needy dog become more independent. However, some dogs are predisposed to neediness due to breed traits or past trauma, in which case an owner should be patient and compassionate.
Expert Opinion
Many dog experts have weighed in on whether there are significant behavioral differences between male and female dogs. Dr. Katherine Houpt, an animal behaviorist at Cornell University’s College of Veterinary Medicine, states “The biggest difference between the sexes is in the frequency with which they urinate to mark their territory. Although female dogs as well as males do this, the behavior is much more common in males.”
Professional dog trainer Victoria Stilwell has worked with dogs for over 20 years, and notes, “My own empirical studies find no differences between male and female dogs in areas like intelligence, ability to learn, memory, curiosity, playfulness, etc. Much of this perception of difference is rooted in anthropomorphism.”
Long-time breeder Joan Hall echoes this sentiment, saying “In my 40+ years breeding dogs, I’ve found very little difference between male and female dogs beyond the obvious physical differences. Both genders have the full range of personality types and temperaments. Claims of broad behavioral differences seem to rely more on stereotyping than actual evidence.”
While some subtle differences in hormone-influenced behaviors exist between male and female dogs, experts agree that viewing dogs’ personalities through a gendered lens often leads to biased assumptions not backed by scientific data.
Conclusion
In reviewing the key points, while there is considerable individual variation in dog behavior and personality regardless of gender, some general differences between male and female dogs do seem to emerge.
Male dogs, especially intact males, tend to be more assertive, energetic, and independent. They are often more intent on exploring their surroundings and marking their territory. In contrast, female dogs are often more reserved, focused on bonding, and easier to train. Of course, neutering and spaying can greatly reduce these gender-related tendencies.
However, factors like training, socialization, breed traits, and owner engagement play huge roles as well. Some female dogs exhibit more “male” behaviors and vice versa. An owner’s treatment and training approach can significantly shape a dog’s neediness and personality.
So while gender may influence a dog’s behavior, it does not rigidly determine it. With thoughtful care and training, boy and girl dogs can become equally well-adjusted, loving companions.