Doggy Backpack or Doggy Frontpack? The Great Carrier Debate

Introduction

When taking your dog for a walk or hike, you have a choice between carrying them on the front or back of your body. Both positions have their pros and cons and may work better depending on your dog’s size and temperament. Carrying your dog can provide them a break from walking, allow them to enjoy new sights and smells, and strengthen your bond.

When carried on the front of your body, either in your arms or a carrier, your dog is close to your face and you can easily interact with them. However, having your dog’s weight on your front can throw off your balance and posture over time. Carrying on the back distributes their weight more evenly and frees up your arms, but doesn’t allow the same level of affection and attention.

In this article, we’ll compare the advantages and disadvantages of carrying your dog on the front vs back. You’ll also find tips to make either position more comfortable for you and your pup.

Pros of Carrying Dog on Front

Carrying your dog on the front of your body provides several advantages. One of the biggest pros is that it allows you to more easily monitor your dog. When your dog is right in front of you, you can keep an eye on their face and body language, check if they seem anxious or uncomfortable, and react quickly if any issues arise. Having your dog within your sight also makes it easier to ensure their safety in crowded areas.

Carrying your dog on your front can also help strengthen the bond between you. Your dog feels comforted and protected being so close to you, while you also feel more connected having them snuggled against your body. This position allows for more physical contact and can be especially comforting for anxious dogs.

Finally, holding your dog close to your chest helps provide a sense of comfort and familiarity if they are feeling nervous or stressed. The soothing rhythm of your breathing and heartbeat can have a calming effect and relieve anxiety in dogs when they are held against your front.

Cons of Carrying Dog on Front

Carrying your dog in front of you can have some disadvantages to consider. One potential issue is that having your dog’s weight in the front can throw off your balance and posture. The uneven distribution of weight towards your front can cause you to lean forward or arch your back, putting strain on your back muscles. This is especially true if your dog is large or wiggly. Constantly having to adjust your posture to accommodate your dog’s shifting weight in front can lead to back pain or stiffness over time.

In addition, holding your dog in front requires using your arms and upper body to support their weight. This can quickly lead to fatigue in your arms, shoulders, and upper back. The longer you carry your pup this way, the more taxing it becomes on those muscle groups. For dog owners with existing upper back/shoulder issues, carrying all that weight up front can exacerbate those problems. An achy upper back or sore shoulders are common side effects.

Overall, the imbalanced weight distribution and use of your upper body to bear your dog’s weight are the primary drawbacks of carrying your pup in front. While it can be done safely, especially for short distances, it’s important to listen to your body and switch to carrying your dog on your back if you start experiencing pain, discomfort or fatigue.

Pros of Carrying Dog on Back

Carrying your dog on your back has some advantages over carrying them on your front. Here are some of the main pros of having your dog ride on your back:

Better for Balance and Posture

a person with better posture while carrying dog on back.

Having the extra weight of your dog on your back can actually help improve your balance and posture. The weight on your back provides a counterbalance to your front, helping you stand up straighter. This makes carrying your dog on your back more ergonomic for your body over longer periods.

Keeps Dog Away from Your Face

For dogs that tend to get in your face a lot, carrying them on your back keeps them further away. This prevents them from covering your face in sloppy kisses or distracting you. It also reduces the chances of them agitating your allergies.

Leaves Arms and Hands Free

With your dog on your back, you don’t have to hold onto them to keep them secure. This leaves your arms and hands completely free. You can get tasks done or hold additional items without worrying about also having to hold your pup.

Cons of Carrying Dog on Back

While there are some benefits to carrying your dog on your back, there are also some downsides to consider.

One major con is that it can be harder to monitor your dog when they’re on your back. You can’t see them as easily and it may be difficult to know if they’re comfortable, need to be let down, etc. Having your dog behind you reduces your ability to keep an eye on them.

Carrying on the back may also be more uncomfortable for your dog. They have less support on your back than on your front, depending on the carrier. Their view is obstructed and they may feel more isolated and insecure when behind you.

Additionally, dogs with shorter legs may have more trouble getting situate and balanced on your back. They could slip or feel like they don’t have enough support. Taller dogs also run the risk of bumping their head on you if they sit up.

In general, the lack of visibility and direct support when carrying your dog on your back can make it more difficult for both you and your pup. Keeping a close eye on your dog and ensuring their comfort is easier when they’re in front.

Front vs Back for Small Dogs

When it comes to small dogs, carrying them on the front is often better than carrying them on the back. There are a few key reasons for this:

Visibility – With a small dog on your front, you can easily see them at all times. This allows you to monitor their comfort level and make adjustments if needed. It’s much harder to see a small dog when carried on your back.

a person struggling to see small dog carried on back.

Balance – A small dog adds little weight when carried on the front. This makes it easier to maintain your balance and posture. Putting a small dog on your back can throw off your center of gravity.

Bonding – Carrying a small dog on your front promotes bonding through the close physical contact. Your dog can look up and see your face, which is reassuring for them.

Temperature – On the front of your body, you can better share body heat with a small dog. This helps keep them warm if it’s chilly outside.

In summary, for small dogs under 15 pounds or so, carrying them on the front is usually the best option. The visibility, balance, bonding, and temperature regulation make the front carry ideal. Just be sure to choose a front-facing dog carrier made for small breeds.

Front vs Back for Large Dogs

When it comes to larger dog breeds, it is generally better to carry them on your back rather than your front. Here are some of the main reasons why:

First and foremost, large dogs can be very heavy. Carrying all that weight on your front can put a lot of strain on your back, shoulders, and neck. The back is better designed to bear heavier loads without injury.

a person straining to carry large dog on front.

On a similar note, having a large dog strapped to your chest can affect your balance and mobility. Their weight being concentrated on your front makes it harder to walk normally. With the dog on your back, the weight is centered and easier to manage.

Large dogs also take up a lot more space than smaller breeds. Carrying them on your front means they obscure your vision and ability to use your arms freely. With the dog secured on your back in a carrier, you’ll have full visibility and range of motion.

Additionally, large dogs tend to be more calm and relaxed when carried on the back. Being strapped to your chest can overstimulate them as they see everything from your vantage point. The back offers them a place to rest their head and enjoy the ride.

For the comfort and safety of both you and your large four-legged friend, opting for a back carrier is the best option.

Tips for Carrying Dog on Front

If you decide to carry your dog on the front of your body, there are some tips to make it more comfortable and safe for both you and your pooch:

Use a carrier. Look for a dog carrier backpack or sling specifically designed for carrying your dog on your front. The right carrier will help distribute your dog’s weight more evenly and prevent strain on your back and shoulders. Make sure to pick a carrier suitable for your dog’s size and weight.

Distribute weight evenly. Position the carrier so your dog’s weight is centered on your front. Tighten straps as needed so the carrier is secure and not pulling down on one side. Wearing your dog centered on your chest or abdomen will prevent you from becoming lopsided.

Take breaks. Carrying any additional weight on your front for a prolonged time can cause muscle fatigue. Take short breaks to set your dog down and give your back and shoulders a rest.

Tips for Carrying Dog on Back

When carrying your dog on your back, there are some tips to follow for the comfort and safety of both you and your pup.

The best way to carry a dog on your back is in a special dog backpack designed for the purpose. Look for a backpack made specifically to carry pets, with a structure that properly supports the dog’s weight. It should distribute the load across your hips and core muscles rather than putting pressure on your shoulders. Make sure to select the right size backpack for your dog’s weight.

Consider your dog’s temperament as well. An active or anxious dog may not enjoy being confined in a backpack for an extended time. Get them used to the backpack gradually. Place treats inside so they associate it with a positive experience.

Take the backpack for short test walks before longer treks. Monitor your dog for signs of discomfort. Adjust any straps as needed to distribute weight. Bring extra water and collapsible dog bowls to provide water breaks.

Carrying a dog on your back takes some conditioning. Start with lighter weights and shorter distances. Build up endurance over time. Make sure to take regular breaks to avoid fatigue and muscle strain.

With the right backpack and some training, carrying your dog can allow you to bring them along on hikes, camping trips, and other adventures safely and comfortably!

Conclusion

In summary, there are pros and cons to carrying dogs both on the front and the back. Carrying a dog on the front allows for more interaction and bonding, but can be tiring on the arms. The back is ergonomically better for the owner, but doesn’t allow the dog to see their face. Small dogs may prefer being carried up front where they can look around more, while large dogs are likely too heavy for this.

Overall, there is no universally “right” way to carry a dog. It depends on your dog’s size, temperament, and personal preference. Be sure to frequently switch up front and back carrying to distribute the physical workload. Pay attention to your dog’s signals to identify their favorite spot. And get a sturdy dog carrier designed for your dog’s weight if carrying for extended periods.

a person frequently switching front and back carry.

The most important thing is supporting your dog’s body fully, not letting them dangle. Carry them in a way that’s comfortable for both of you. Your dog will let you know if they don’t like a certain carrying position. As long as your dog feels secure and close to you, they’ll enjoy the ride!

Scroll to Top